A Broken Man – A Review

A Broken Man by Akash Verma

A broken man

The story

A Broken Man is the story of Krishna, A Dalit boy from a small village in Bihar and his love story with a Brahmin girl Chhavi from Lucknow. The two are students at the Lucknow University, which is where they meet and fall in love. Forced to choose between Krishna and her father, Chhavi chooses her father. A broken-hearted Krishna makes his way to Mumbai with a box full of belongings and Chhavi’s recommendation for a job at an advertising agency. Then on, the story traces his journey as he makes his way from the ad-world to tinsel town.

What I liked

I begin with a disclaimer of sorts. I picked up this book because of its setting – my hometown Lucknow. And it scores a perfect six on that front. As the story took me through the campus, the departments I’d been to, the library I’d passed a thousand times, the restaurant I go to even now, it left me with a warm nostalgic feeling.

My personal liking apart, A Broken Man captures student life at the Lucknow University to a tee. The hullaballoo of the election, the speeches, the street plays, the student politics – all just as it happens.

While there wasn’t much to the story I did like the way it was told. The bits of Hindi poetry were beautiful, the little grandma’s stories that Chhavi picks, endearing.

Also, I loved how Chhavi remains a part of Krishna’s life, how he constantly summons her in his imagination at every significant point in his life – at each moment of doubt, at each victory.

What I didn’t like

Editing editing editing. I am wary of new Indian authors for this reason alone and A Broken Man proves my point yet again. Phrases like ‘KK took a waited look’ (What is a waited look??), ‘KK had eyes that ached of pain’a drink from the well-stuffed bar (how about ‘well-stocked’?), stand out like sore thumbs.

The narrative is teeming with adverbs (The author would do well to read Stephen King’s On Writing, a very useful book for writers, aspiring or otherwise) and repetitions.

Take this instance – The blurb reads ‘high caste Brahman girl’.  Either Brahman or high caste should suffice, specially on a blurb. Am I nitpicking? Maybe. But the thing is, it can get tiresome when it goes on page after page.

There is much ‘tell’ and less ‘show’.

Lastly there are some factual errors. I know this is fiction not fact, and allows for liberties, but because I applauded the book for its real-life representation of the University campus it is only fair I point out the flaws too.

One, A girl could never ever walk into a Lucknow University boys’ hostel in 90s. I’m not sure it’s possible even now.

Two, a Dalit boy cannot arrive in a village with an obviously high caste girl (‘she can’t pass off as a Dalit girl…. her skin glows like fresh milk’. The author’s words, not mine), be seen by the high caste men and go without comment or action. Nothing remains a secret in a village. She will most definitely not be left in peace to make out with the Dalit boy by the side of the pond in the middle of the night. Just not possible.

Then, there’s Mumbai. Without adding spoilers, all I’ll say is that the story in Mumbai, becomes overly simplistic and predictable.

In the end I’d call it a simple story that could have been better told – pick it or leave it.


Disclaimer: I received a copy of the book from Writers Melon in return for an honest and unbiased review.

17 Replies to “A Broken Man – A Review”

  1. I so hear you on the editing errors. It takes a lot away from the story. I am scared to pick up a new author for just this reason.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This isn’t so with new authors only Lata. Even those with a number of books to their credit continue with editing errors. Maybe much of the audience just does’t care.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. After reading the story you shared in the beginning, I knew why you read this book and you mentioned just that later on! 🙂 Am glad that it did not disappoint you on that front.
    I remember picking a book simply because it had Shimla as its backdrop. And I enjoyed it too simply because Shimla was a like a character in the story. Rest was just as you mentioned in The Broken Man…. predictable / no story and poor editing! 😐

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ha ha you do know me well. What IS it with the editing? And I thought that would be the easy part. I mean Indians are good with the English language, aren’t we? Why can’t we find decent editors? Strange.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I can understand a couple of errors in self-published books (ahem, ahem :)), however, not justified, but these days it’s common to spot editing errors in books by renowned publishing houses. Surprising and disappointing!

    Nice review. I got a chance to read this book but I presumed I would not like it. It becomes difficult for me if the book is a review copy. I can’t leave it unread.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This was an easy read Tarang. It wasn’t superbly edited but it did flow well. So it wasn’t much of a trial. I get impatient with editing errors because I think they can avoided and speak of careless presentation.


  4. Editing – it’s completely overlooked by the Indian publishing industry for the most part. Clearly more of an issue with the indie books, but even the main stream ones do a very shoddy job of it.

    And no, you are not nitpicking. I can completely understand, because I overlook these things at times. But page after page, it gets tiresome.


  5. That was a really honest and well-done review. Editing is my big gripe too and the factual errors you mentioned should have been taken care of for sure. Does not seem likely that I will pick up this book.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Rachna. There’s nothing a little bit of attention and research can’t set right. Sigh!


Like it? Love it? Hate it? Say something.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: